[[management-resources]]
= Management resources

ifdef::env-github[]
:tip-caption: :bulb:
:note-caption: :information_source:
:important-caption: :heavy_exclamation_mark:
:caution-caption: :fire:
:warning-caption: :warning:
endif::[]

When WildFly parses your configuration files at boot, or when you use
one of the AS's <<Management_Clients,Management Clients>> you are
adding, removing or modifying _management resources_ in the AS's
internal management model. A WildFly management resource has the
following characteristics:

[[address]]
== Address

All WildFly management resources are organized in a tree. The path to
the node in the tree for a particular resource is its _address_. Each
segment in a resource's address is a key/value pair:

* The key is the resource's _type_, in the context of its parent. So,
for example, the root resource for a standalone server has children of
type `subsystem`, `interface`, `socket-binding`, etc. The resource for
the subsystem that provides the AS's webserver capability has children
of type `connector` and `virtual-server`. The resource for the subsystem
that provides the AS's messaging server capability has, among others,
children of type `jms-queue` and `jms-topic`.
* The value is the name of a particular resource of the given type, e.g
`web` or `messaging` for subsystems or `http` or `https` for web
subsystem connectors.

The full address for a resource is the ordered list of key/value pairs
that lead from the root of the tree to the resource. Typical notation is
to separate the elements in the address with a '/' and to separate the
key and the value with an '=':

* `/subsystem=undertow/server=default-server/http-listener=default`
* `/subsystem=messaging/jms-queue=testQueue`
* `/interface=public`

When using the HTTP API, a '/' is used to separate the key and the value
instead of an '=':

* `http://localhost:9990/management/subsystem/undertow/server/default-server/http-listener/default`
* `http://localhost:9990/management/subsystem/messaging/jms-queue/testQueue`
* `http://localhost:9990/management/interface/public`

[[operations]]
== Operations

Querying or modifying the state of a resource is done via an operation.
An operation has the following characteristics:

* A string name
* Zero or more named parameters. Each parameter has a string name, and a
value of type `org.jboss.dmr.ModelNode` (or, when invoked via the CLI,
the text representation of a `ModelNode`; when invoked via the HTTP API,
the JSON representation of a `ModelNode`.) Parameters may be optional.
* A return value, which will be of type `org.jboss.dmr.ModelNode` (or,
when invoked via the CLI, the text representation of a `ModelNode`; when
invoked via the HTTP API, the JSON representation of a `ModelNode`.)

Every resource except the root resource will have an `add` operation and
should have a `remove` operation ("should" because in WildFly {wildflyVersion} many do
not). The parameters for the `add` operation vary depending on the
resource. The `remove` operation has no parameters.

There are also a number of "global" operations that apply to all
resources. See <<Global_operations,Global operations>> for full
details.

The operations a resource supports can themselves be determined by
invoking an operation: the `read-operation-names` operation. Once the
name of an operation is known, details about its parameters and return
value can be determined by invoking the `read-operation-description`
operation. For example, to learn the names of the operations exposed by
the root resource for a standalone server, and then learn the full
details of one of them, via the CLI one would:

[source,options="nowrap"]
----
[standalone@localhost:9990 /] :read-operation-names
{
    "outcome" => "success",
    "result" => [
        "add-namespace",
        "add-schema-location",
        "clean-obsolete-content",
        "composite",
        "delete-snapshot",
        "full-replace-deployment",
        "list-add",
        "list-clear",
        "list-get",
        "list-remove",
        "list-snapshots",
        "map-clear",
        "map-get",
        "map-put",
        "map-remove",
        "product-info",
        "query",
        "read-attribute",
        "read-attribute-group",
        "read-attribute-group-names",
        "read-children-names",
        "read-children-resources",
        "read-children-types",
        "read-config-as-xml",
        "read-config-as-xml-file",
        "read-operation-description",
        "read-operation-names",
        "read-resource",
        "read-resource-description",
        "reload",
        "reload-enhanced",
        "remove-namespace",
        "remove-schema-location",
        "replace-deployment",
        "resolve-expression",
        "resolve-internet-address",
        "resume",
        "shutdown",
        "suspend",
        "take-snapshot",
        "undefine-attribute",
        "upload-deployment-bytes",
        "upload-deployment-stream",
        "upload-deployment-url",
        "validate-address",
        "validate-operation",
        "whoami",
        "write-attribute",
        "write-config"
    ]
}
[standalone@localhost:9990 /] :read-operation-description(name=upload-deployment-url)
{
    "outcome" => "success",
    "result" => {
        "operation-name" => "upload-deployment-url",
        "description" => "Indicates that the deployment content available at the included URL should be added to the deployment content repository. Note that this operation does not indicate the content should be deployed into the runtime.",
        "request-properties" => {"url" => {
            "type" => STRING,
            "description" => "The URL at which the deployment content is available for upload to the domain's or standalone server's deployment content repository.. Note that the URL must be accessible from the target of the operation (i.e. the Domain Controller or standalone server).",
            "expressions-allowed" => false,
            "required" => true,
            "nillable" => false,
            "min-length" => 1L,
            "max-length" => 2147483647L,
            "web-url" => true,
            "stability" => "default"
        }},
        "reply-properties" => {
            "type" => BYTES,
            "description" => "The hash of managed deployment content that has been uploaded to the domain's or standalone server's deployment content repository.",
            "expressions-allowed" => false,
            "required" => true,
            "nillable" => false,
            "min-length" => 20L,
            "max-length" => 20L,
            "stability" => "default"
        },
        "access-constraints" => {"application" => {"deployment" => {"type" => "core"}}},
        "stability" => "default",
        "read-only" => false,
        "runtime-only" => true
    }
}
----

See <<descriptions,Descriptions>>
below for more on how to learn about the operations a resource exposes.

[[attributes]]
== Attributes

Management resources expose information about their state as attributes.
Attributes have string name, and a value of type
`org.jboss.dmr.ModelNode` (or: for the CLI, the text representation of a
`ModelNode`; for HTTP API, the JSON representation of a `ModelNode`.)

Attributes can either be read-only or read-write. Reading and writing
attribute values is done via the global `read-attribute` and
`write-attribute` operations.

The `read-attribute` operation takes a single parameter "name" whose
value is a the name of the attribute. For example, to read the "port"
attribute of a socket-binding resource via the CLI:

[source,options="nowrap"]
----
[standalone@localhost:9990 /] /socket-binding-group=standard-sockets/socket-binding=https:read-attribute(name=port)
{
    "outcome" => "success",
    "result" => 8443
}
----

If an attribute is writable, the `write-attribute` operation is used to
mutate its state. The operation takes two parameters:

* `name` – the name of the attribute
* `value` – the value of the attribute

For example, to read the "port" attribute of a socket-binding resource
via the CLI:

[source,options="nowrap"]
----
[standalone@localhost:9990 /] /socket-binding-group=standard-sockets/socket-binding=https:write-attribute(name=port,value=8444)
{"outcome" => "success"}
----

Attributes can have one of two possible _storage types_:

* *CONFIGURATION* – means the value of the attribute is stored in the
persistent configuration; i.e. in the `domain.xml`, `host.xml` or
`standalone.xml` file from which the resource's configuration was read.
* *RUNTIME* – the attribute value is only available from a running
server; the value is not stored in the persistent configuration. A
metric (e.g. number of requests serviced) is a typical example of a
RUNTIME attribute.

The values of all of the attributes a resource exposes can be obtained
via the `read-resource` operation, with the "include-runtime" parameter
set to "true". For example, from the CLI:

[source,options="nowrap"]
----
[standalone@localhost:9990 /] /subsystem=undertow/server=default-server/http-listener=default:read-resource(include-runtime=true)
{
    "outcome" => "success",
    "result" => {
        "allow-encoded-slash" => false,
        "allow-equals-in-cookie-value" => false,
        "always-set-keep-alive" => true,
        "buffer-pipelined-data" => true,
        "buffer-pool" => "default",
        "bytes-received" => 0L,
        "bytes-sent" => 0L,
        "certificate-forwarding" => false,
        "decode-url" => true,
        "disallowed-methods" => ["TRACE"],
        "enable-http2" => false,
        "enabled" => true,
        "error-count" => 0L,
        "max-buffered-request-size" => 16384,
        "max-connections" => undefined,
        "max-cookies" => 200,
        "max-header-size" => 1048576,
        "max-headers" => 200,
        "max-parameters" => 1000,
        "max-post-size" => 10485760L,
        "max-processing-time" => 0L,
        "no-request-timeout" => undefined,
        "processing-time" => 0L,
        "proxy-address-forwarding" => false,
        "read-timeout" => undefined,
        "receive-buffer" => undefined,
        "record-request-start-time" => false,
        "redirect-socket" => "https",
        "request-count" => 0L,
        "request-parse-timeout" => undefined,
        "resolve-peer-address" => false,
        "send-buffer" => undefined,
        "socket-binding" => "http",
        "tcp-backlog" => undefined,
        "tcp-keep-alive" => undefined,
        "url-charset" => "UTF-8",
        "worker" => "default",
        "write-timeout" => undefined
    }
}
----

Omit the "include-runtime" parameter (or set it to "false") to limit
output to those attributes whose values are stored in the persistent
configuration:

[source,options="nowrap"]
----
[standalone@localhost:9990 /] /subsystem=undertow/server=default-server/http-listener=default:read-resource(include-runtime=false)
{
    "outcome" => "success",
    "result" => {
        "allow-encoded-slash" => false,
        "allow-equals-in-cookie-value" => false,
        "always-set-keep-alive" => true,
        "buffer-pipelined-data" => true,
        "buffer-pool" => "default",
        "certificate-forwarding" => false,
        "decode-url" => true,
        "disallowed-methods" => ["TRACE"],
        "enable-http2" => false,
        "enabled" => true,
        "max-buffered-request-size" => 16384,
        "max-connections" => undefined,
        "max-cookies" => 200,
        "max-header-size" => 1048576,
        "max-headers" => 200,
        "max-parameters" => 1000,
        "max-post-size" => 10485760L,
        "no-request-timeout" => undefined,
        "proxy-address-forwarding" => false,
        "read-timeout" => undefined,
        "receive-buffer" => undefined,
        "record-request-start-time" => false,
        "redirect-socket" => "https",
        "request-parse-timeout" => undefined,
        "resolve-peer-address" => false,
        "send-buffer" => undefined,
        "socket-binding" => "http",
        "tcp-backlog" => undefined,
        "tcp-keep-alive" => undefined,
        "url-charset" => "UTF-8",
        "worker" => "default",
        "write-timeout" => undefined
    }
}
----

See <<descriptions,Descriptions>>
below for how to learn more about the attributes a particular resource
exposes.

[[overridden-attribute-value]]
=== Override an Attribute Value with an Environment Variable

It is possible to override the value of any simple attribute by providing an environment variable with a name
that maps to the attribute (and its resource).

[NOTE]
====
Complex attributes (which have their `type` set to `LIST, OBJECT`, or `PROPERTY`) can not be overridden using an environment variable.
====

If there is an environment variable with such a name, the management resource will use the value of this environment variable
when the management resource validates and sets the attribute value.
This takes place before the attribute value is resolved (if it contains an expression) or corrected.


[NOTE]
====
This feature is disabled by default. To enable it, the environment variable `WILDFLY_OVERRIDING_ENV_VARS` must be set (its value is not relevant):

`export WILDFLY_OVERRIDING_ENV_VARS=1`
====

==== Mapping between the resource address and attribute and the environment variable

The name of the environment variable is based on the address of the resource and the name of the attribute:

1. take the address of the resource (e.g. `/subsystem=undertow/server=default-server/http-listener=default`)
** `/subsystem=undertow/server=default-server/http-listener=default`
2. remove the leading slash (`/`)
** `subsystem=undertow/server=default-server/http-listener=default`
3. append *two underscores* (`__`) and the name of the attribute (e.g. `proxy-address-forwarding`)
** `subsystem=undertow/server=default-server/http-listener=default__proxy-address-forwarding`
4. Replace all non-alphanumeric characters with an underscore (`_`) and put it in upper case
** `SUBSYSTEM_UNDERTOW_SERVER_DEFAULT_SERVER_HTTP_LISTENER_DEFAULT__PROXY_ADDRESS_FORWARDING`

If WildFly is started with that environment variable, the value of the `proxy-address-forwarding` attribute on the
`/subsystem=undertow/server=default-server/http-listener=default` will be set to the value of the environment variable:

[source,nowrap]
----
$ WILDFLY_OVERRIDING_ENV_VARS=1 \
  SUBSYSTEM_UNDERTOW_SERVER_DEFAULT_SERVER_HTTP_LISTENER_DEFAULT__PROXY_ADDRESS_FORWARDING=false \
  ./bin/standalone.sh
$ ./bin/jboss-cli.sh -c --command="/subsystem=undertow/server=default-server/http-listener=default:read-attribute(name=proxy-address-forwarding)"
{
    "outcome" => "success",
    "result" => "false"
----

[NOTE]
====
If an attribute value is determined from an environment variable, the next time the configuration is persisted, that value from the environment variable will be persisted.
Until an operation triggers such persistence of the configuration file, the configuration file will not reflect the current running configuration.
====

[[children]]
== Children

Management resources may support child resources. The
<<address,_types_ of children>> a
resource supports (e.g. `connector` for the web subsystem resource) can
be obtained by querying the resource's description (see
<<descriptions,Descriptions>> below)
or by invoking the `read-children-types` operation. Once you know the
legal child types, you can query the names of all children of a given
type by using the global `read-children-types` operation. The operation
takes a single parameter "child-type" whose value is the type. For
example, a resource representing a socket binding group has children. To
find the type of those children and the names of resources of that type
via the CLI one could:

[source, yaml]
----
[standalone@localhost:9990 /] /socket-binding-group=standard-sockets:read-children-types
{
    "outcome" => "success",
    "result" => ["socket-binding"]
}
[standalone@localhost:9990 /] /socket-binding-group=standard-sockets:read-children-names(child-type=socket-binding)
{
    "outcome" => "success",
    "result" => [
        "http",
        "https",
        "jmx-connector-registry",
        "jmx-connector-server",
        "jndi",
        "remoting",
        "txn-recovery-environment",
        "txn-status-manager"
    ]
}
----

[[descriptions]]
== Descriptions

All resources expose metadata that describes their attributes,
operations and child types. This metadata is itself obtained by invoking
one or more of the <<Global_operations,global operations>> each
resource supports. We showed examples of the `read-operation-names`,
`read-operation-description`, `read-children-types` and
`read-children-names` operations above.

The `read-resource-description` operation can be used to find the
details of the attributes and child types associated with a resource.
For example, using the CLI:

[source, yaml]
----
[standalone@localhost:9990 /] /socket-binding-group=standard-sockets:read-resource-description
{
    "outcome" => "success",
    "result" => {
        "description" => "Contains a list of socket configurations.",
        "head-comment-allowed" => true,
        "tail-comment-allowed" => false,
        "attributes" => {
            "name" => {
                "type" => STRING,
                "description" => "The name of the socket binding group.",
                "required" => true,
                "head-comment-allowed" => false,
                "tail-comment-allowed" => false,
                "access-type" => "read-only",
                "storage" => "configuration"
            },
            "default-interface" => {
                "type" => STRING,
                "description" => "Name of an interface that should be used as the interface for any sockets that do not explicitly declare one.",
                "required" => true,
                "head-comment-allowed" => false,
                "tail-comment-allowed" => false,
                "access-type" => "read-write",
                "storage" => "configuration"
            },
            "port-offset" => {
                "type" => INT,
                "description" => "Increment to apply to the base port values defined in the socket bindings to derive the runtime values to use on this server.",
                "required" => false,
                "head-comment-allowed" => true,
                "tail-comment-allowed" => false,
                "access-type" => "read-write",
                "storage" => "configuration"
            }
        },
        "operations" => {},
        "children" => {"socket-binding" => {
            "description" => "The individual socket configurtions.",
            "min-occurs" => 0,
            "model-description" => undefined
        }}
    }
}
----

Note the
`"operations" => }} in the output above. If the command had included the {{operations`
parameter (i.e.
`/socket-binding-group=standard-sockets:read-resource-description(operations=true)`)
the output would have included the description of each operation
supported by the resource.

See the <<Global_operations,Global operations>> section for
details on other parameters supported by the `read-resource-description`
operation and all the other globally available operations.

== Comparison to JMX MBeans

WildFly management resources are conceptually quite similar to Open
MBeans. They have the following primary differences:

* WildFly management resources are organized in a tree structure. The
order of the key value pairs in a resource's address is significant, as
it defines the resource's position in the tree. The order of the key
properties in a JMX `ObjectName` is not significant.
* In an Open MBean attribute values, operation parameter values and
operation return values must either be one of the simple JDK types
(String, Boolean, Integer, etc) or implement either the
`javax.management.openmbean.CompositeData` interface or the
`javax.management.openmbean.TabularData` interface. WildFly management
resource attribute values, operation parameter values and operation
return values are all of type `org.jboss.dmr.ModelNode`.

[[basic-structure-of-the-management-resource-trees]]
== Basic structure of the management resource trees

As noted above, management resources are organized in a tree structure.
The structure of the tree depends on whether you are running a
standalone server or a managed domain.

=== Standalone server

The structure of the managed resource tree is quite close to the
structure of the `standalone.xml` configuration file.

* The root resource
** `extension` – extensions installed in the server
** `path` – paths available on the server
** `system-property` – system properties set as part of the
configuration (i.e. not on the command line)
** `core-service=management` – the server's core management services
** `core-service=service-container` – resource for the JBoss MSC
`ServiceContainer` that's at the heart of the AS
** `subsystem` – the subsystems installed on the server. The bulk of the
management model will be children of type `subsystem`
** `interface` – interface configurations
** `socket-binding-group` – the central resource for the server's socket
bindings
*** `socket-binding` – individual socket binding configurations
** `deployment` – available deployments on the server

=== Managed domain

In a managed domain, the structure of the managed resource tree spans
the entire domain, covering both the domain wide configuration (e.g.
what's in `domain.xml`, the host specific configuration for each host
(e.g. what's in `host.xml`, and the resources exposed by each running
application server. The Host Controller processes in a managed domain
provide access to all or part of the overall resource tree. How much is
available depends on whether the management client is interacting with
the Host Controller that is acting as the Domain Controller. If
the Host Controller is the Domain Controller, then the section of
the tree for each host is available. If the Host Controller is a secondary Host Controller
to a remote Domain Controller, then only the portion of the tree
associated with that host is available.

* The root resource for the entire domain. The persistent configuration
associated with this resource and its children, except for those of type
`host`, is persisted in the `domain.xml` file on the Domain Controller.
** `extension` – extensions available in the domain
** `path` – paths available on across the domain
** `system-property` – system properties set as part of the
configuration (i.e. not on the command line) and available across the
domain
** `profile` – sets of subsystem configurations that can be assigned to
server groups
*** `subsystem` – configuration of subsystems that are part of the
profile
** `interface` – interface configurations
** `socket-binding-group` – sets of socket bindings configurations that
can be applied to server groups
*** `socket-binding` – individual socket binding configurations
** `deployment` – deployments available for assignment to server groups
** deployment-overlay -- deployment-overlays content available to
overlay deployments in server groups
** `server-group` – server group configurations
** host – the individual Host Controllers. Each child of this type
represents the root resource for a particular host. The persistent
configuration associated with one of these resources or its children is
persisted in the host's `host.xml` file.
*** `path` – paths available on each server on the host
*** `system-property` – system properties to set on each server on the
host
*** `core-service=management` – the Host Controller's core management
services
*** `interface` – interface configurations that apply to the Host
Controller or servers on the host
*** `jvm` – JVM configurations that can be applied when launching
servers
*** `server-config` – configuration describing how the Host Controller
should launch a server; what server group configuration to use, and any
server-specific overrides of items specified in other resources
*** `server` – the root resource for a running server. Resources from
here and below are not directly persisted; the domain-wide and host
level resources contain the persistent configuration that drives a
server
**** `extension` – extensions installed in the server
**** `path` – paths available on the server
**** `system-property` – system properties set as part of the
configuration (i.e. not on the command line)
**** `core-service=management` – the server's core management services
**** `core-service=service-container` – resource for the JBoss MSC
`ServiceContainer` that's at the heart of the AS
**** `subsystem` – the subsystems installed on the server. The bulk of
the management model will be children of type `subsystem`
**** `interface` – interface configurations
**** `socket-binding-group` – the central resource for the server's
socket bindings
***** `socket-binding` – individual socket binding configurations
**** `deployment` – available deployments on the server
**** deployment-overlay -- available overlays on the server
